You wouldn't tell My Mother?
During this consultation, Miss Smith seeks the doctor’s help because she fears telling her mother the truth about her health. The recording begins with the patient explaining that the doctor’s receptionist had put Miss Smith in a problematic situation. The incident occurred because the receptionist mistakenly told the patient’s mother that she was at the practice that day without Miss Smith’s permission. Miss Smith, in her trust of the doctor, confided her worry that her mother might find out she was using birth control pills.
Will you lie about Thrush?
At first, Miss Smith initially asked the doctor if he would lie to her mother by saying she was there for thrush treatment instead of birth control. This lie stunned the doctor. He immediately declines Miss Smith’s offer, and his respect for the family and his empathy for their situation guide his decision.
Miss Smith has reached the legal age of consent.
Later, he emphasizes that she is legally over 17 and can have private discussions with her physician without informing her guardians. This legal protection of patient-doctor confidentiality ensures that the doctor can keep the conversation between them if his patient wishes. In addition, the doctor suggested to Miss Smith that he could inform her mother about her use of birth control pills if she wished. On the contrary, it was the last thing that Miss Smith wanted.
Miss Smith requested that the consultation remain private and that her mother not be informed. The doctor reassured Miss Smith of his commitment to patient confidentiality, promising not to disclose anything to her mother. However, he stressed that he would not lie to her mother about the thrush. He told her that if she wanted to tell her mother herself, she could do so, as he would not lie. The doctor found himself in a challenging situation. He didn’t want to betray his patient’s trust or be forced to lie to her mother.
Consequently, he remained firm that she would not participate in the deception. The discussion ended with the daughter reluctantly accepting the problematic situation.
Should the receptionist have informed her mother about her presence at the practice?
As Miss Smith is now at an age where patient confidentiality is strictly enforced to help keep the patient from harm, the answer to the question is “No.”
It seems that the receptionist may have breached confidentiality by sharing sensitive information. Missing information could potentially harm the patient’s trust and lead to abuse or verbal disputes. Addressing this misconduct is crucial, as the patient’s trust is paramount in our profession.
An employer could take various actions to address employee misconduct effectively. These actions may include revising disciplinary measures, providing retraining, conducting a thorough review of company policies, and offering new materials. Implementing these measures can significantly improve how information is managed within the organisation, leading to more effective handling of similar situations in the future.
Keep yourself updated and maintain patient privacy. Check out these five additional strategies by experts for handling various situations.
Should the doctor lie for me?
Attempting to persuade the doctor to provide false information to your mother on your behalf is not ethical or respectful. It places the doctor in a difficult position as they commit to honesty and the well-being of their patients. Communicating openly and honestly with your doctor and mother is essential to ensure a respectful and effective resolution to any concerns or issues.
© 2022 All Rights Reserved.